Website Logo
CriticalPixel
Gaming Deals
CriticalPixel

Find game deals, reviews and community picks in one place.

//Deals

  • All game deals
  • All-time lows
  • Free to play
  • New releases

//By price

  • Up to $5
  • Up to $10
  • Up to $20
  • Up to $30

//Stores

  • Steam
  • Instant Gaming
  • Gamivo
  • Green Man Gaming
  • Kinguin
  • YuPlay
  • IndieGala
  • GameBillet

//Platforms

  • Steam
  • Epic Games
  • GOG
  • PlayStation
  • Xbox
  • Nintendo

//Explore

  • All games
  • Genres
  • Top 10 lists
  • Articles
  • Community
  • Release calendar

//CriticalPixel

  • About
  • Creators program
  • Contact
  • Press
© 2026 CriticalPixelMade in Brazil

Legal

  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Terms of Service

    Embark Swapped The Finals Casters for Its Own AI Voices, Then Pulled the Video and Apologized

    By CriticalPixel · 2026-11-18

    Embark Swapped The Finals Casters for Its Own AI Voices, Then Pulled the Video and Apologized

    Embark Studios built a highlight reel for the biggest tournament its own shooter has ever run, and then decided the people who actually called those matches were optional. The recap of The Finals APAC Closed Qualifiers went up with commentary from Scotty and June, the game's fictional AI announcers, replacing the live casters who had worked the broadcast. Within a day the video was deleted, the two follow-up recaps in the same format were scrapped, and a studio lead was posting an apology on his personal account. That is not a small scheduling slip. That is a company shipping a product that told its own esports talent they were replaceable, then discovering the internet disagreed loudly enough to matter.

    The Finals competitors pushing through a destructible arena during a match

    The details matter here. The Grand Major is Embark's official circuit for the game, run with FACEIT and DreamHack, and the APAC Closed Qualifiers feed into it. Caster Proto / Kai said the team had been through four cycles of open and closed qualifiers, all the prep, all the late nights, and then heard two AI voices narrating the run, including lines that quoted the human casters back at themselves. Bluepanda, who worked the same broadcast, said the decision came after nearly seven years of being told the work was valued. Both of them found out the way everyone else did, by watching the video.

    Embark's own statement, given to IGN, admits the shape of it: the team selected clips from the broadcast, wrote a new script, and produced fresh commentary for Scotty and June. The company framed it as a way to introduce more players to The Finals esports before the Grand Major, then conceded that leaving out the casters and talent who made that broadcast was not the right call. Oscar Lundberg, who runs competitive experience and community at Embark, put it more plainly on X: it was a mistake, and he was sorry. The video is down, and it will not come back in that form.

    This is not a fan trailer, it is the front door of a $200,000 circuit

    Worth keeping the scale in view. According to The Finals Wiki, the 2026 Grand Major carries a $200,000 prize pool split between $150,000 for the main event and $50,000 across the online series, with the finals staged at DreamHack Stockholm in Season 12. That is real money and a real stage, and the recap video was the marketing arm of it. When the promotional layer of a competitive scene decides that the voices selling the matches can be generated, the message lands on every caster in every region wondering if their next contract is a line item someone wants to cut.

    It also did not come out of nowhere. The Finals launched Dynamic Commentary on October 20, a feature that lets Scotty and June call out specific plays and address players by their in-game names during a live match. Embark has been open about leaning on AI voice work elsewhere too, defending the synthetic voices in Arc Raiders earlier this month by arguing it was impractical to record every possible version of every item line. Scotty and June are performed by paid human voice actors whose voices were licensed for the system, which is exactly the awkward part. The studio is not using random robot noise. It is using a model built from people who did the job, to do the job without them.

    The Finals squad trading fire across a collapsing city block

    The casters read the apology and kept walking

    The response from the people at the centre of it was not gratitude. Bluepanda told PC Gamer that Embark saw no issue until the backlash went global, and that the follow-up amounted to a shrug about not expecting people to mind. In her words, that reads as a studio that is not really sorry. She said she is done with the game and with esports for now, which is a brutal thing to hear from someone with seven years in the scene. Proto / Kai called the whole thing a shit show and pushed for something more structural than an apology: an esports talent union, with contracts that explicitly block generative use of casters' voices.

    The backlash also escaped The Finals entirely, which is usually the signal that a studio misjudged the room. Marvel Rivals caster LemonKiwi called the move appalling and said the real casters deserved better, adding that the generated commentary was not even good. League of Legends caster Sam Hapgood used the word dystopian. Fighting game commentator Damascus pointed out the grim mechanics of it, that the AI voices were effectively trained on the same talent being pushed out. That is a cross-scene reaction from people with no stake in Embark's game, and it tells you how the labour side of esports reads this.

    Where the defenders have a point

    Not everyone hated it, and the split is worth being honest about. Some The Finals players genuinely like Dynamic Commentary in match, arguing that a system reacting to real events in real time adds something a pre-recorded line pack cannot. One reply to Proto / Kai with a couple dozen likes made exactly that case, that the in-game feature is impressive even if the esports decision stank. Those are two different products. A reactive announcer inside your own match is a toy. Firing the humans who called your tournament and running the toy over their highlight reel is a labour decision, and Embark blurred the two on purpose because the second one is cheaper.

    The Finals cashout objective under pressure from multiple teams

    The CriticalPixel take

    Embark did not pull that video because someone had a change of heart about casters. It pulled the video because the reaction was loud enough to cost more than the recap saved, and the apology arrived with the same energy as a refund issued after a chargeback. The company had already shipped the tooling, already published the feature, already told the world that recording every voice line was too expensive. Then it pointed that logic at the people who build its competitive scene for free attention and called it outreach. If the goal was bringing casual players into The Finals esports, the casters are the asset, not the obstacle. They are the ones who make a match legible to someone who has never watched one.

    The fix is not complicated. Keep the human broadcast audio in the recap, pay the talent for the cut, and if you want Scotty and June in the package, put them beside the casters instead of on top of them. Embark says the AMER and EMEA recaps are being rethought, and that is the moment to prove it, because those two videos are the test of whether this was a correction or a pause until attention moves on. Watch whether the talent gets contracts with explicit voice protections, and watch whether the casters who spoke up are still on the next broadcast. That is the part of this story that will actually tell you what Embark decided.

    Sources

    PC Gamer, Embark apologizes for replacing esports casters with AI voices in deleted The Finals video

    IGN, esports casters call for change after The Finals AI commentator swap

    Proto / Kai on X, replaced by two AI casters after four qualifier cycles

    Oscar Lundberg on X, apology for the APAC Closed Qualifier recap

    THE FINALS on Steam, official store page and screenshots

    THE FINALS Wiki, The Grand Major 2026 prize pool and organisers

    //GAMES IN THIS ARTICLE

    • The Finals

    Games featured: The Finals.